The Best Pizza in Toledo

1 M Osteria Bar & Lounge

M Osteria Bar & Lounge offers an upscale dining experience with their meticulously crafted pizzas. Known for its trendy ambiance, M Osteria’s sausage and peppers pizza is especially recommended. This place not only serves delightful pizza but also ensures a memorable evening with a great atmosphere and impeccable service.

2 Home Slice Pizza

Home Slice Pizza brings New York-style thin crust pizzas to downtown Toledo with a twist. Their potato pizza, a combination of A1 steak sauce, potatoes, and cheese, is a memorable experience. The friendly and bustling environment makes it a fantastic spot for a casual meal with friends or family.

3 Pizza Papalis

Pizza Papalis is the go-to for lovers of deep-dish pizza. Their gourmet creations, like the meat eater’s deluxe or the classic Chicago style, are perfect for those extra hungry moments. Located conveniently in Toledo, it’s an excellent choice for family dinners or big group outings.

4 The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar prides itself on delivering perfect NYC-style pizza. Their white ricotta pizza is a standout, balancing flavors beautifully. The welcoming and lively atmosphere, coupled with a great selection of craft beers, makes it a favorite among locals.

5 J-Cups Pizza

J-Cups Pizza excels in offering a wide variety of specialty pizzas. The BBQ Mac & Cheese Pizza is a hit, offering a fun and delicious twist on traditional pizza. The staff’s friendliness and the cozy environment add to the overall fantastic dining experience.

7 Arturo's Pizza Kitchen

Arturo's Pizza Kitchen offers flavorful options like the cayenne chicken pizza, which perfectly balances spice and taste. Their dedication to quality and service has earned them a loyal customer base. It’s no wonder this spot is a top choice for many in Toledo.

8 Mazzas Stone Baked Pizza Co.

Mazza’s Stone Baked Pizza Co. delivers some of the best stone-baked pizza in Toledo. The Detroit-style pizza, with its crispy edges and rich toppings, is particularly beloved. Friendly service and excellent value make this family-owned pizzeria a local gem.

9 Le Pam Pam Pizza & Subs

Le Pam Pam Pizza & Subs is well-loved for its Mediterranean twists on pizza, such as the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It’s a perfect spot for a quick, delicious meal. The friendly staff and casual atmosphere add to the appeal, making it a reliable go-to for pizza lovers.

10 Jomaa Brothers Pizza

Jomaa Brothers Pizza stands out for its generous toppings and consistently good service. The chicken club pizza comes highly recommended, packed with flavor. It’s a trusted choice for many in Toledo looking for a satisfying pizza experience.