Address: 1122 N Byrne Rd Unit 15, Toledo, OH 43607

Phone: +1 419 536 9295

Price Range: $$$$

Website: https://www.fishermenoh.com

Fishermen

Step into Fishermen Fish and Chicken, located at 1122 N Byrne Rd Unit 15 in Toledo, Ohio, and you're met with a nostalgic fast-food vibe, specializing in seafood and chicken dishes. While some patrons rave about the crispy fried catfish and perfectly cooked wings, others report inconsistent experiences, ranging from great to downright disappointing.

Let's talk appetizers. The Classic Sampler, priced at $8.99, offers a mix of chicken strips, cheese sticks, jalapeno poppers, and onion rings - a decent variety, though the execution can be hit or miss. The Jalapeno Poppers and Cheese Sticks are crowd favorites, often coming out crispy and filled with gooey cheese, but the Onion Rings and Fried Okra sometimes suffer from undercooking or overly greasy natures. For a sidekick, their Hush Puppies should be crunchy but sometimes fall victim to an overly high grease temperature, leaving them too hard on the outside but still soft inside.

Among the seafood options, the Catfish Fillets ($10.34) and Ocean Perch ($10.34) emerge as popular picks. When fried to the right crispiness, the catfish can be satisfying, especially with a splash of their homemade tartar sauce. However, inconsistencies in quality are a recurring issue. Some customers enjoy fresh, crispy fish, while others encounter fishy smells and sliminess indicative of it nearing its expiration.

Chicken dishes at Fishermen have earned mixed reviews. The Chicken Wings, available at $11.49, are often praised for their flavor, though seasoning is sometimes uneven. The Buffalo Chicken Strips ($12.64) come with a kick of spice, but sporadic seasoning and grease issues detract from the overall experience.

The sandwich selection attempts to diversify the menu, and while the Fish Sandwich ($9.19) is a standout when it's well-prepped, it can occasionally fall short with mushy bread and underwhelming fish. The Original Gyro ($8.61), loaded with gyro meat, onions, tomatoes, and homemade tzatziki sauce, is a solid choice, balancing tangy and savory flavors well. Yet, grills like the Buffalo Fried Chicken Sandwich ($9.19) face similar inconsistency complaints.

For those who thrive on sweet endings, the Cheesecake ($4.01) is an okay option to conclude your meal, though it's not particularly memorable.

Fishermen Fish and Chicken is open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to midnight, and Sunday until 11:00 PM. It's primarily a carryout joint, with no dine-in option currently available. An important tip: it's best to consume your food shortly after picking it up to avoid any cold or soggy mishaps.

Reservations aren't necessary, but be prepared for potential miscommunications based on some reports about poor phone etiquette and wrong order instances.

Ultimately, while Fishermen holds potential with some hidden gems among its offerings, consistency seems to be the Achilles' heel. If you're willing to roll the dice, their catfish, wings, and gyros might just hit the spot on a good day.