Address: 2001 Starr Ave, Toledo, OH 43605

Phone: +1 419 720 1990

Price Range: $$$$

Website: https://www.facebook.com/pizzaman419/

Guy's Pizza

Guy's Pizza, located at 2001 Starr Ave in Toledo, Ohio, has been a local favorite for years, and for good reason. Known for its phenomenal service and consistently high-quality food, this spot has become a go-to for residents and visitors alike. One of the key aspects setting Guy’s Pizza apart is the cleanliness and care they put into everything, from their kitchen to their customer service. This commitment is evident whether you're grabbing a quick takeout or dining in.

Pizza lovers, this is your paradise. One standout is the all-meat pizza, loaded with fresh, high-quality meats, a robust sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. The crust is another highlight - perfectly baked and delicious, making each bite a treat. For those who prefer a different kind of indulgence, the double bacon cheeseburger with onion rings is a must-try. This loaded burger hits all the right notes with its juicy patties and crispy onion rings, making it a heavy hitter on the menu. If you're looking to branch out, the pepperoni and sausage pizza also comes highly recommended.

The calzones here are another crowd-pleaser. Packed with cheese and a choice of two items, they make for a satisfying meal. The medium calzone is particularly popular, filled with gooey cheese and your choice of meats or veggies. Don’t forget to try their signature sauce—it adds a perfect finishing touch. Another great option is their large calzone, which is enormous and ideal for sharing.

Salads at Guy’s Pizza are not your average side dish—they're a hearty meal in their own right. The Italian salad is fresh and generously portioned, loaded with tomatoes, onions, black olives, and a blend of cheeses. The grilled chicken salad takes it up a notch with tender, flavorful chicken and crispy bacon. The crispy chicken salad is another hit, combining crunchy chicken with the freshness of a well-made salad. Dressing options include French, ranch, or house Italian, all adding their unique touch to the already tasty salads.

Apart from pizzas and salads, the pasta dishes here are worth mentioning. The homemade meat spaghetti sauce is a favorite and, when paired with their garlic bread, makes for a comforting meal. The chicken Alfredo pasta offers a creamy delight, while the chicken Parmesan pasta is breaded and cooked to perfection.

For those looking at fried options, the fried dinners are a hit. The chicken dinner, including breast, thigh, wing, and drumstick, is incredibly juicy and flavorful, served with fries or onion rings, coleslaw, and a roll. The chicken strip dinner is generous with an 8 oz portion, making it a perfect choice for a lazy evening. Popcorn shrimp and boneless wing dinners also come with sides and are worth trying.

Guy's Pizza also serves a variety of subs and burgers. The steak sub stands out, filled with seasoned sliced steak, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers topped with cheese, making it a hearty, satisfying option. The cheeseburgers here are equally compelling, reportedly flavorful and generously sized.

If you’re up for some appetizers, the deep-fried pickle chips and mozzarella sticks are terrific starters. They also offer loaded fries in different styles, including bacon and cheese or pepperoni and cheese, which are great for sharing.

While the food is a major draw, the atmosphere and service at Guy's Pizza add to the overall experience. The staff is usually very friendly and the delivery service is prompt. It’s primarily a dine-in and takeout spot, open from 2 PM to 10 PM most days, extending to 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

One thing to note is that some customers have mentioned discrepancies in price, so it might be a good idea to confirm the total when ordering. However, this minor inconvenience is often overshadowed by the good quality food and friendly service.