Address: 611 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43604

Phone: +1 419 214 4222

Price Range: $$$$

Website: http://mosteriatoledo.com

M Osteria Bar & Lounge

M Osteria Bar & Lounge is a trendy Italian spot in downtown Toledo that features a blend of old-world charm and modern elements. Owned by entrepreneur Pat Giammarco, the restaurant is housed in a beautifully restored historic building, boasting high beamed ceilings and exposed brick walls that exude a modern twist. The ambiance is posh yet inviting, making it an ideal location for a range of dining experiences, from casual bites to celebratory dinners.

Their menu is a fusion of traditional Italian classics and artisan creations, promising something for every palate. Among the must-try starters are the meatballs and arancini, both repeatedly highlighted for their excellence. The meatballs are a special treat, bursting with flavor and perfectly complemented by a pomodoro sauce that adds just the right amount of tanginess.

Moving on to the main courses, there are some hits and misses. The salmon entrée receives high praise for its perfect seasoning and texture. It's a standout dish that exemplifies the quality of ingredients used here. However, the Carbonara has proven divisive, with some diners finding it overwhelms with pepper, which can be a bit much for those expecting a more traditional balance of flavors. Meanwhile, the Cavatelli fails to impress with its underwhelming portion sizes and bland taste, despite being described as a classic dish.

Pizza enthusiasts will be delighted with the selection available. The Margherita Pizza is a popular choice, lauded for its thin, crispy crust and fresh mozzarella. Similarly, the Sausage and Pepper Pizza offers a mouth-watering combination of flavors and is highly recommended by many patrons. However, be prepared for a hefty price, as two pizzas and drinks can set you back around $30.

Dessert here does not disappoint. The Lemoncello Cake comes highly recommended, offering a delightful, zesty end to the meal. Dessert options rotate monthly, ensuring that there’s always something new to try, crafted with seasonal inspirations.

The service at M Osteria is the most polarizing aspect of the dining experience. While some servers, like the acclaimed 'Susie', leave guests with a bitter taste due to their rude demeanor and unprofessional behavior, others excel in making diners feel welcome and attended to. This inconsistency in service quality can make or break an evening, as evidenced by several negative experiences shared by patrons.

M Osteria accepts reservations for parties of four or more but be aware that walk-ins are always welcome. Despite this, planning ahead is advisable to avoid any potential disappointment or mishaps with seating arrangements. The restaurant also features free street parking in downtown Toledo after 6 PM on weekdays and all day on weekends, which is a nice convenience for those driving in.

While M Osteria shines with its impressive atmosphere and some standout dishes, such as the salmon and the pizzas, it doesn’t come without its share of flaws. The dining experience can vary greatly depending on your timing and the staff on duty. If you're a fan of Italian cuisine and are willing to take a bit of a gamble, this might just become a favorite spot in Toledo.