Address: 101 Main St #7, Toledo, OH 43605

Phone: +1 419 698 2988

Price Range: $$$$

Website: http://www.michaelsoftoledo.com

Michael's Cafe & Bakery

With a long-standing reputation as a cozy spot for lunch and delicious baked goods, Michael's Cafe & Bakery in downtown Toledo has continued to draw locals and visitors alike to the historic Weber Block building since its founding in 1980. Known for its homemade pastries, soups, and sandwiches, Michael’s has a nostalgic charm that pairs beautifully with its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. 😋

Let’s first talk about their bread – it’s freshly made on-site and serves as the perfect base for their hefty and satisfying sandwiches. The Mighty Maumee, loaded with roast beef, roast turkey, ham, Swiss and Pepperjack cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and onion, sets a high bar for deli sandwiches, and at $12.50, it offers substantial value for your buck.

Die-hard fans of hearty sandwiches shouldn't miss the Monroe Street Melt. It's a classic Cuban twist with smoked pulled pork, ham, Swiss, and American cheeses, pickles, mustard, all pressed Panini-style on a white hoagie. It's a mouthful of rich, smoky flavors that leave you wanting more.

On the flip side, if you’re a fan of spicier options, the Angry Mudhen might be your new favorite. This hoagie-style sandwich features Cajun chicken, Cajun sauce, Provolone cheese, and the usual lettuce, tomato, and onion on a sun-dried tomato basil hoagie. It packs a punch, especially with the extra kick from the Cajun sauce. 🌶️ However, opinions on the Cajun Chicken Hoagie have been mixed, with some diners finding it a bit too greasy and gristly on certain visits.

For a lighter, slightly sweeter option, the Easy Street sandwich is a crowd-pleaser. Smoky turkey breast paired with candied bacon and American cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, and Dijon-Parmesan sauce served on toasted Vienna bread strikes a balance between savory and sweet that is delightfully satisfying.

Salads at Michael’s are also worth a try, with fresh, vibrant ingredients that shine in both their standalone offerings and as side options with entrees. The Field Greens Salad, topped with smoked Gouda, candied pecans, dried cherries, and crumbled bacon, all drizzled with homemade raspberry vinaigrette, makes for a flavorful and light choice that doesn't skimp on taste.

Now, let’s talk desserts, which might just be the highlight of Michael’s. Their cheesecake has been deemed one of the best around, but you can't leave without trying their Key Lime Pie. It’s tangy, creamy, and often described by loyal patrons as the best they’ve ever had. Their eclairs and biscuits also come highly recommended, complementing perfectly brewed coffee for a nice midday treat.

While the food generally receives high praise, there have been occasional slips in service quality, with some diners feeling they were treated differently compared to others. Also, it’s good to note their mixed reviews on the shrimp and fries; it’s best to stick with their sandwiches and baked goods to get the most out of your visit.

Dining in at Michael’s provides a cozy, old-school experience. If you’re planning to visit during the busy lunch hours, be prepared for a bit of a wait and potential parking challenges due to its prime downtown location. Michael's does offer delivery services, and it’s highly rated for catering, making it a smart choice for business lunches or family gatherings.

Michael's Cafe & Bakery operates Monday to Friday from 8 AM to 3 PM and is closed on Sundays. For those considering a visit, it’s a good idea to call ahead for takeout or customization requests, especially during peak times.