Address: 4034 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43606

Phone: +1 419 214 1640

Price Range: $$$$

Website: https://www.pizzacat.com

Pizza Cat

Pizza Cat, established in 2017 and located at 4034 Monroe Street in Toledo, is a haven for pizza enthusiasts. The joint stands out not just for its delectable offerings but also for its unique commitment to accommodate various dietary preferences. Their eclectic selection includes options like vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, and keto crusts, making it a true celebration of inclusivity in the culinary world 🌍.

The creativity at Pizza Cat is palpable from the moment you glance at the menu. The variety spans from classic pepperoni to more imaginative combinations like the brisket pizza and Rueben pizza. The brisket pizza is particularly noteworthy: perfectly cooked brisket on a savory sauce with a crust that's crispy yet chewy in all the right ways. If you're looking for something that leans into the decadent side, the Mini Meat pizza, stacked generously with meats and oozing with cheese, is a must-try.

Despite the rave reviews about the flavor, one consistent critique is the misleading size of the pizzas. Many diners have noted that the 9” pizza often measures closer to 7”, which might be disappointing if you're expecting to feed a crowd. However, the taste seems to make up for it according to several patrons.

Now, let’s talk about the gluten-free and keto options. The gluten-free cauliflower crust has received positive feedback for its texture and flavor, which doesn't scream 'health food.' On the other hand, the keto crust, made with chicken, is a game-changer for those counting carbs. One innovative customer even combined two keto pizzas to create a double-decker delight – a pro-tip if you’re feeling adventurous!

Pizza Cat's 'Pink Pizza,' for example, combines a blush sauce with ample cheese to create a luscious, creamy experience that leaves a lasting impression. Then there's the 'Cheese and Bacon' gluten-free option, which has a substantial following. The pizza is generously topped, and the crust holds its own despite the toppings.

What's particularly striking about Pizza Cat is their dedication to maintaining high-quality ingredients across the board. Their sauce, often described as exquisite, perfectly balances the acidity and sweetness, elevating each bite. The Northend Brisket with an optional add of pineapple is another combination that hits all the right notes, creating a harmonious blend of savory and sweet.

However, keep in mind that Pizza Cat operates as a carry-out and delivery-only establishment. With no indoor seating, the only option for on-site dining is a couple of picnic tables outside, which might not be ideal during Toledo's unpredictable weather. That said, their efficient service means you won't be waiting long to take your pizza home or to the nearest park.

Operating hours for Pizza Cat are quite accommodating, opening as early as 10 AM and staying open until midnight most days, with extended hours until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. This makes it a convenient late-night food stop🍕, especially for night owls or anyone catching a late show or gathering in the area.