Address: 27 Broadway St, Toledo, OH 43604

Phone: +1 419 243 1302

Price Range: $$$$

Website: https://rockwells.mbaybrew.com

Rockwell's Steakhouse

Rockwell’s Steakhouse, situated in the historic Oliver House in downtown Toledo, sets a sophisticated backdrop for a night out. However, a string of recent reviews indicates a mixed bag of experiences that you might want to consider before making a reservation.

For starters, the ambiance is notably elegant but has small quirks — brighter-than-expected LED lighting and the creaky wooden floors of its historic building. The service has been inconsistent. Some have praised the attentiveness, while others have criticized the long waits for refills and the general lack of knowledge about fine dining service standards.

On the culinary side, Rockwell’s offers a wide range of appetizers that are generally well-regarded. The Calamari and Crab Cakes are crowd favorites and seem to consistently hit the mark. As for salads, the Caesar Salad and Wedge Salad stick to the classics, and the Steakhouse Spinach Salad offers a more unique flavor with its bacon vinaigrette.

When it comes to the main courses, there’s a split opinion. The Filet Mignon and 14 oz. Prime-Aged New York Strip have been described as well-prepared and flavorful by some, but others have reported issues with seasoning and cooking precision. One guest noted their steak was overcooked and dry, challenging the restaurant’s reputation for high-quality cuts.

The seafood options like the Seafood Pasta and Lobster Mac and Cheese have also received mixed reviews. While some diners praised the dishes for their uniqueness and taste, others found them lacking in flavor or complained about improperly cooked ingredients, such as unopened mussels in the pasta.

Don't skip the accompaniments if you can help it. The Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Shaved Brussels Sprouts with prosciutto are often highlighted as being well seasoned and complementing the main dishes excellently.

For dessert, the Cheesecake and Crème Brûlée appear to be beloved across the board, warranting a try if you have a sweet tooth. They offer a satisfying conclusion to the meal even if the main course left something to be desired.

The reservation policies are straightforward: Rockwell's operates from Thursday to Saturday from 5 pm to 9 pm, and Sundays from 12 pm to 9 pm. Given the ambiance and potential for a varied dining experience, it may be best to visit during off-peak hours to get the most attentive service. Don’t forget to enter through the back of the building for easier access.