Address: 615 Riverside Dr, Toledo, OH 43605

Phone: +1 567 315 8048

Price Range: $$$$

Website: http://oldbagofnails.com/

The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Toledo

Visiting 'The Old Bag of Nails Pub' in Toledo feels like stepping into a cozy corner of New England smack in the Midwest. The pub's warm, rustic ambiance—believe me when I say they're nailing the wooden furniture and vintage decor vibe—makes it an inviting spot for anything from a casual bite to a relaxed evening out. Kicking things off, their beer selection is pretty stellar, with plenty of local brews to satisfy any beer aficionado.

Let's dive into the star of the menu: their famous Fish and Chips. These aren't just any fish and chips, folks. We're talking two hefty pieces of perfectly battered, golden goodness. The fish is fresh, generously portioned, and delicious, making it a must-try if it's your first visit. Just a heads-up: the coleslaw sometimes shares space with the hot fish in the same container, which makes it a bit warm if you get it to-go. But the flavor still holds up.

Another highlight is the All-You-Can-Eat Shrimp on Wednesdays. You get to choose from four flavors, and you can switch it up between rounds. The blackened and grilled shrimp options are top-notch, tender and packed with flavor. For drinks, the Peach Bourbon Tea pairs incredibly well, adding a sweet and tangy kick to your meal.

If appetizers are more your style, start with the Fried Button Mushrooms. They come perfectly battered with a horseradish dipping sauce that packs a perfect punch. Their Chicken Nachos are also a crowd-pleaser, smothered with black bean dip, salsa, and cheese, and topped with grilled chicken, jalapenos, and scallions.

Carnivores will appreciate the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, loaded with shaved tender sirloin, sautéed onions, peppers, mushrooms, and gooey white American cheese. On the seafood front, the Mussels & Jumbo Shrimp dish, steamed in white wine and butter, is a hidden gem. It's served with garlic bread that's perfect for soaking up all that delicious broth.

Let’s talk desserts because you won’t want to skip them. The Bread Pudding is a fan favorite, as is the Carrot Cake. Both desserts are generous in portion size, so you might want to share—or take some home to extend the deliciousness a bit longer.

Pro tip: The outdoor seating here is fantastic, especially on a warm day. Enjoy a meal with a view of the river, which adds an extra layer of charm to the whole experience. Service is friendly and attentive, contributing to a laid-back yet polished dining atmosphere.

Keep in mind that reservations are accepted, which is great because this place can get busy. While the pub caters to various dining preferences with kid-friendly options, vegetarian dishes, and flexible seating arrangements, its comfort food classics truly shine.