Address: 3115 West Bancroft Street, Toledo, Ohio, USA, 43606

Phone: +1 419 720 1818

Price Range: $$$$

Website: https://stubbornbrother.com

The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar in Toledo, Ohio, is a family-owned gem started by John and Gabrielle Mancy, whose passion for East Coast pizza shines through every slice they serve. They're committed to an 'old world style' of pizza making, emphasized by using local ingredients, even down to their NYC-replicated water. The vibe here is casual and cool, with an open, modern space, perfect for catching a game or just hanging out with friends. They've even got garage doors that open up into the dining room when the weather plays nice. 🌞

When it comes down to the food, The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar packs a punch. The menu offers a broad selection, from pizzas to wings, and even a few hearty subs. For starters, their Twice Baked Garlic Rolls ($11.99) are a must-try. These rolls, smothered in garlic butter and pizza cheese, make for a decadent, mouthwatering bite.

One of the highlights of the menu is undoubtedly the pizza. Their New York-style pizza stands out with its thin, crispy crust and quality toppings. The Rocco's Meat Lover ($29.99) piles on the pepperoni, fennel sausage, and Italian ham, making it a meaty delight. However, feedback is mixed on the ricotta-laden pies like the Spicy Sicilian ($29.99). Some found the ricotta texture off-putting, so it might be best to stick to what you love.

If you’re more inclined towards a veggie option, Gracie's Veggie Pizza ($28.99) comes highly recommended. The combination of caramelized onions, roasted mushrooms, sweet peppers, and roasted garlic makes it a flavorful and satisfying choice. And for those days when you’re craving meat but want to switch it up, their Chicago Beef Sub ($16.49) is another fan favorite, boasting tender beef and an amazing dipping sauce. GO NOW!

Their pasta bowls (starting at $9.49) offer a customizable option, but stick with the classics if you're feeling wary. Something sweeter to end your meal? The Brownie Sundae might hit the spot. 🍨

However, not everything is sunshine and rainbows. Service appears to be a hit or miss. While many have found the staff attentive and polite, others have reported long waits and inattentive service. This inconsistency can be a bummer, especially when your goal is to enjoy a relaxed meal.

The ambiance strikes a chord with many customers. It's modern, clean, and offers a great space to unwind. However, it seems that some may find the pizza slices that sit around to be reheated a bit off-putting. Freshly-made, specialty pizzas tend to be the way to go to ensure you're getting the best experience possible.

To wrap it up, The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar offers good food in a relaxed setting. It's worth visiting for the New York-style pizza and unique menu offerings. Just be mindful of the occasional hiccups in service, and time your visit right to avoid potential delays. 🍕🕰️